6 Comments
User's avatar
Public1940's avatar

I am thankful Numlock made me aware of this book. Elizabeth Catte has a PhD in Public History. She cites sources in abundance. I experienced Hillbilly Elegy as a dishonest book when I read it. J T Vance has presented the characters in Hillbilly Elegy as THE APPALACHIA. Catte shows us a whole other region full of different individuals--people who have fought for justice, workers' rights, decent wages, etc. for decades. She cites J. T. Vance's sources: "Vance cites racist-thinking far more directly than even is critics have indicated." (quoting John Thomason). And the people that Vance presents as Appalachia...one can find drug addicts, drunks, people who don't want to work, people who are always shooting themselves in the foot in all parts of the country. He writes about a type of person and he ties that type of person to the geography of where they live...which is ridiculous when you think about it. Elizabeth Cadde also shows definitively how corporate decisions and corporate actions have decimated the country side, taken good work away, set up situations where people who can get work are paid pitifully and taken advantage of. Appalachia is complex and certainly not limited to the kind of people who are in J. T. Vance's family...he takes his family and extrapolates them as all Appalachia is. Cadde offers factual information about working class voters (and not just white working class voters) in Appalachia. I wish this book were better known. I grew up in Appalachia though I don't live there now (and wish I did.) I know first hand that Hillbilly Elegy is a lie. And now here is a book that a scholar has written that documents the complexity and the rich history of this area in such an important corrective way.

Expand full comment
Walter Hickey's avatar

I loved the book and am glad you enjoyed it as well, it's totally the hopes I had for this fun little book club.

Reading your comment, you may like more from Belt Press https://beltpublishing.com/. I've followed their work a lot, and this was the first book I pushed to the book club vote, and there's a ton of great stuff they produce as a small press. Would highly recommend, they're a great shop.

Expand full comment
Public1940's avatar

Will definitely check Belt Press out!

Expand full comment
Paul Lang's avatar

Good evening. The book has deconstructed simple assumptions of the region to show that, like most everything, it’s a lot more complicated.

I appreciated learning more about the region’s history. The book also recalibrated my vanishing appreciation of how large the geography of “Appalachia” truly is.

I saw Chris Offutt’s blurb and was very excited as he is a tremendous author with keen insights into Kentucky and Appalachian culture through his fiction.

I would recommend it. It reminds you that media tropes are normally just lazy to maintain simplicity in their story lines.

Expand full comment
Walter Hickey's avatar

Hey! I just finished the read. I really loved this one, it felt like such a perfect length and scope and I really learned a lot about the region. I really, really can't stand parachute and diner style journalism and cringed constantly during a lot of 2016 to 2020 over how major institutions handled things. The ideas in this book were really exciting and I loved learning more about the radical history of the region and how the extractive industry sent money to the very people actively oppressing it.

I think the most challenging part for me (in a good way!) is the "a camera is a gun" part. I'm definitely trying to square my profession -- which by definition ampliflies and takes images and broadcasts them in a wide fashion -- into what is owed to the subjects. I don't really think there's a clean answer here, but having more empathy for subjects is definitely a thing I think about a lot and this book really was provocative in a good way for me on that.

Expand full comment
Irish Twilight's avatar

Certainly enjoyed the book, learned some very interesting things about the region and would recommend it to people. The biggest take away I got from this book and reading about this region's working folks is how ill-equipped Hillary Clinton was to reach these voters. Talk about a perfect storm!

Expand full comment